Sinclair Lewis’s George F. Babbitt and Green Acres’ Mr. Haney represent two branches of American enterprise: the businessman who believes his own sales pitch and the businessman who hopes somebody else will. Babbitt requires a community of shared values. Haney requires a deposit.
Both sell property, but their deeper commodity is confidence. Babbitt’s real-estate business belongs to a world of civic clubs, respectable opinions, and collective self-congratulation. Haney achieves comparable effects beside a truck. Where Babbitt needs the organized business leadership of Zenith to certify that commerce serves humanity, Haney is prepared to certify this himself.
Their language reveals the distinction. Babbitt speaks in slogans whose authority comes from everyone repeating them. Haney offers explanations whose ingenuity increases with the customer’s resistance. Babbitt knows a proposition is sound because every successful man agrees. Haney knows a proposition needs work because Mr. Douglas has noticed the roof.
Yet Babbitt possesses something Haney seldom displays: an unhappy inner life. His intermittent rebellion against conformity suggests that prosperity has failed to deliver the existence it advertised. He becomes, in effect, a dissatisfied customer of his own philosophy. Lewis allows him enough self-awareness to suffer, though insufficient independence to make suffering reliably useful.
Haney enjoys the advantages of a recurring comic character. He need not resolve a spiritual crisis before returning next week with a secondhand water heater. His identity survives every exposure because exposure is already included in the business model.
The pairing therefore illuminates two relationships between commerce and belief. Babbitt depends on the conviction that business success establishes moral worth. Haney demonstrates how much business can be conducted after that conviction has become unnecessary.
Babbitt needs to believe he is a pillar of the community. Haney would be pleased to sell him one.
##
Haney / Gecko
Gordon Gekko, the financier of Wall Street, can be understood as Mr. Haney with access to capital markets. In this interpretation, Gekko stands on the shoulders of giants, although Haney would charge him for the ladder.
Both men practice the art of discovering that another person’s assets would be better situated in their own possession. Both present self-interest as a service. Haney arrives when Oliver Douglas needs something; Gekko arrives when a company possesses something. The distinction is modest but consequential.
Their principal difference is rhetorical scale. Haney offers a dubious bargain. Gekko offers a theory of civilization. “Greed is good” elevates the sales pitch into a political philosophy: what benefits the acquisitive individual supposedly improves the system. Haney, working with fewer syllables and a smaller wardrobe budget, generally confines his claims to the exceptional value of the merchandise.
Yet Haney’s world imposes a limitation that Gekko’s financial machinery helps overcome: Haney must usually face the person he is fleecing. Oliver can inspect the tractor, identify its missing parts, and shout. In Wall Street, the proposed dismantling of Bluestar Airlines separates financial opportunity from the workers who will bear its consequences. Distance permits an elegance unavailable in the farmyard.
The comic forms differ accordingly. Haney’s schemes must leave Oliver sufficiently solvent for next week’s episode. Gekko’s ambitions carry no such obligation to preserve the supporting cast. Haney is a recurring nuisance; Gekko threatens the conditions under which the story’s ordinary people can continue living.
Neither comparison requires making Haney an innocent. His advantage is candor by transparency: the audience recognizes the hustle almost immediately. Gekko’s expensive surroundings invite the possibility that predation becomes wisdom above a certain income.
Haney sells you a tractor that does not work. Gekko explains why eliminating your job means the economy does.
