NYT February 1, 2026

CASE STUDY LINK

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/30/well/back-pain-pelvic-congestion-syndrome-nutcracker.html

This should be direct access to the AI dialog (Chat GPT 5.2)

https://chatgpt.com/share/697f8be2-e1dc-8005-b9f0-3927ae024c56

###

This is a NYT diagnostic dilemma patient. Please read the case up to this point and then project a best diagnosis (or more than one if needed). These are not written as cleanly for that decision, as a medical journal case report of the week, but see what you can do. ### Her Sudden Back Pain Was Unbearable. What Could Ease It? For a doctor and a mother of four, there was almost no relief to be found. Listen to this article · 7:50 min Learn more Share full article 155 Credit...Photo illustration by Tomi Um By Lisa Sanders, M.D. Jan. 30, 2026 Sign up for the Well newsletter. Essential news and guidance to live your healthiest life. Get it sent to your inbox. The 42-year-old woman walked with her twin sons and older daughter through the nearly empty walkways at Legoland. She was grateful that her children were old enough to go on the rides without her but sad that she felt too awful to join them. For the past five months, she had been tortured by pain boring into her back, an inch to the left of her spine. It was as if a drill were driving past her ribs to someplace deep inside, so specific, so localized that she felt she could draw a circle around it. She helped her kids board each ride, pointing out the bench where she would be waiting for them. Sitting barely helped — no position was comfortable anymore — but standing for a long time was simply impossible. The pain had come on suddenly. One June morning she woke up, and there it was. When it lasted all day and was still present when she awoke the next morning, she went to the Medstar Georgetown University Hospital emergency room, near her home in Washington. Imaging and blood tests didn’t reveal the cause. She had a pretty significant anemia, she was told. But the medical team didn’t find anything that could have caused this agony. Over the next several months, the pain spread to her left flank, just above her hip bone. It was a pressure-like pain unlike anything she had ever felt. A Life Altered by Pain The woman was a pediatric ophthalmologist. For most of her career, she spent her days on her feet, examining children in her office and at the Children’s National Hospital. It was a physically demanding job. She was often tired, and from the very first days of her residency training, she became lightheaded with the hospital rounds that kept her standing for hours. This despite the fact that she wore prescription-grade compression stockings to help her throbbing varicose veins. Between patients, she often had to rest on the metal trash cans that dotted the hospital hallways. But that — though uncomfortable, and unexpected given her age — was manageable. These new pains in her back and side made patient care too difficult. That fall, she made the transition to a desk job, far away from the part of doctoring that she loved most. Her primary-care doctor and longtime OB-GYN were baffled by her pains. She sought opinions from a long list of subspecialists: a rheumatologist who looked for evidence of an autoimmune disease but found none. A hematologist who suspected that her anemia resulted from her heavy periods but saw nothing more. A specialist in rehabilitation medicine, who sought a cause for her pain in her spinal column but didn’t find that either She had a dozen imaging studies and an uncountable number of tests of her blood and urine. They confirmed the anemia but shed little additional light. She started having trouble sleeping; the only position that didn’t worsen the pain was on her stomach. There were other symptoms, more irritating than painful, but new and hard for her to understand. She developed constant nausea and heartburn. Her appetite vanished, and she lost a lot of weight. She saw a gastroenterologist who found mild gastritis; treating that helped enough that the weight loss subsided. And she couldn’t raise her arms past the level of her shoulders without them falling asleep. After just a few minutes of reading in bed, they would go numb.

####

Oooh this is a good one — the kind where the pain description is doing 80% of the diagnostic work if we trust it.

Let me walk through it like a case conference.

🔑 The Big Clues

1. The pain is:

Sudden onset
Extremely focal — “she could draw a circle around it”
Left paraspinal, then radiating to left flank above the iliac crest
Deep, boring, pressure-like
Not positional, not relieved by rest
Severe enough to change her career

This is not typical musculoskeletal back pain. It behaves more like visceral or vascular pain referred to the back.

2. She has long-standing:

Orthostatic intolerance
Lightheadedness with prolonged standing
Needs compression stockings
Varicose veins at a young age
Has had this since residency

That’s a vascular-autonomic phenotype, not just “tired doctor on rounds.”

3. Other systemic changes over 5 months

Anemia (unexplained beyond “heavy periods”)
Nausea, heartburn, appetite loss, weight loss
Arm numbness when elevated
Can only sleep prone
No autoimmune or spinal cause found

So we have vascular + neurologic + abdominal/GI + constitutional symptoms.

🚩 The Back Pain Location Is a Huge Hint

Pain:

“an inch to the left of her spine,” boring inward toward ribs and flank

That is exactly where the LEFT KIDNEY and renal vessels project posteriorly.

Classic causes of deep unilateral flank/back pain:

Kidney (stone, obstruction, infarct)
Retroperitoneal mass
Vascular structures (renal artery/vein, aorta branches)

But imaging didn’t show a stone or mass.

So think vascular compression.

💥 The Unifying Theme: VASCULAR COMPRESSION SYNDROMES

This case is screaming:

A connective tissue / venous compression disorder

Specifically:

⭐ Most Likely Core Diagnosis:

Nutcracker Syndrome (Left Renal Vein Compression)

Why this fits beautifully:

Finding	Explanation
Severe focal left back/flank pain	Classic for left renal vein compression between aorta & SMA
Anemia	Can occur from chronic hematuria (even microscopic)
Nausea, GI symptoms	Venous congestion can affect abdominal circulation
Weight loss	Often seen due to chronic pain + GI distress
Worse over time	Venous hypertension can progress
Only comfortable prone	Position may reduce venous compression

Nutcracker syndrome pain is often described as:

deep, boring, flank or paraspinal pain

Exactly this.

🌿 But There’s More — This Isn’t Just Nutcracker

She also has:

🔹 Long-standing orthostatic intolerance

🔹 Varicose veins

🔹 Arms going numb when elevated

That constellation strongly suggests:

Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS), hypermobile type

→ leading to multiple vascular compression syndromes

EDS predisposes to:

Venous laxity
Vessel displacement
Collapsible venous structures
Autonomic dysfunction (POTS-like)

🧠 The Arm Numbness Is Another Clue

Arms go numb when elevated

That’s classic for:

Thoracic Outlet Syndrome (TOS)

Especially venous or neurogenic TOS:

Compression of subclavian vein/brachial plexus when arms elevated
Causes numbness, heaviness, paresthesias

TOS is strongly associated with EDS.

🧩 Putting It Together

This is not a single-organ disease.

This is a vascular compression disorder cluster, most likely due to underlying connective tissue laxity.

Best Unifying Diagnosis:

🧠 Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome with Multiple Vascular Compression Syndromes

With:

Nutcracker syndrome → explains the back/flank pain + anemia
Thoracic outlet syndrome → explains arm numbness with elevation
Autonomic dysfunction / POTS physiology → explains lifelong orthostatic lightheadedness
Possibly pelvic venous congestion → heavy periods, venous symptoms

❌ What This Is Not

Condition	Why it doesn’t fit
Kidney stone	Would show on imaging, colicky, episodic
Disc herniation	Would be positional, radicular
Pancreatitis	Wrong location, labs would show
Autoimmune	Workup negative
Cancer	Imaging reportedly clean
Fibromyalgia	Pain too focal and vascular-feeling

🧪 What Test Would Prove It?

The diagnostic move would be:

Doppler ultrasound or CT/MR venography looking for:

Compression of left renal vein
Collateral veins
Elevated renal vein velocities
Aorto-mesenteric angle narrowing

And evaluation for thoracic outlet compression.

🎯 Final Answer

Most likely primary diagnosis:

Nutcracker Syndrome (Left Renal Vein Compression)

Underlying condition:

Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome with autonomic dysfunction

Associated secondary diagnosis:

Thoracic Outlet Syndrome

If this were presented at grand rounds, the “aha” moment would be:

“This isn’t back pain. This is a venous hypertension syndrome in a connective tissue patient.”

Absolute classic “missed for months” NYT Diagnosis story setup.

Here is the rest of the article. Read and discuss concisely. ### The woman, frustrated by the lack of answers, began to review her own medical records. She noticed that several of the imaging studies reported a finding she had never heard of: pelvic congestion syndrome. She asked her doctors about it, but none of them thought it was likely to be the cause of the symptoms she had developed. Pelvic congestion syndrome (P.C.S.) occurs when blood doesn’t move through the veins normally, whether because of some kind of obstruction or because the valves that normally keep blood moving against gravity, back toward the heart, stop working. This causes the veins coming from the organs in the pelvis, including the uterus and ovaries, to dilate and blood to pool — a type of varicose vein of the pelvic vessels. Like varicose veins on the more visible parts of the body, P.C.S. is more common in women who have had children because pregnancy itself causes the vessels to enlarge. Patients with this syndrome often describe a kind of pelvic heaviness and report that sex becomes painful. While P.C.S. is a common cause of pelvic pain, many women with no pain at all have imaging that shows some evidence of the syndrome. So the significance of the finding is not always clear to physicians. Editors’ Picks Where Moguls and Movie Stars Go for Clothes How to Make Friends as an Adult I Was Bullied for Being Gay. Why Didn’t My Parents Do More to Help? Image Credit...Photo illustration by Tomi Um Crucial Help From a Friend As the woman read about the various causes of pelvic congestion, her interest was piqued by the colorfully named nutcracker syndrome. In this unusual disorder, a change in anatomy — often weight loss — spurs a shift in the position of a large blood vessel called the superior mesenteric artery, causing it to press on the vein draining the left kidney and blocking the flow of blood through the vessel. The blood that needs to return to the heart and lungs to be reoxygenated and repumped has to find a new path from the kidney back to the heart. The unimpeded veins fatten with the additional blood, and new collateral veins form. These changes cause pelvic congestion. The woman was intrigued. The location of her pain seemed close to where the compression would be happening. She called a gynecologist friend. Had she ever heard of nutcracker syndrome? Was it a thing? Her friend was quiet for a moment. “Not really,” she answered. That was discouraging to hear, and yet, as the woman read more about the symptoms, it seemed as if she were reading about herself. Last summer, two years after her pain first started, the woman and her husband invited two friends, a couple, over for lunch. The husband, Emmett Lynskey, is an interventional radiologist who specializes in treating pelvic pain and fibroids. He and his wife had known the woman since medical school and ended up practicing in the same hospital. Because of their long friendship, the woman felt comfortable bringing up the topic of her pain at lunch. She hoped he would offer to review her scans, and he did. She gave him written permission and crossed her fingers. That night, her phone buzzed. “Took a look at your M.R.I.,” Lynskey texted. “Pretty sure you have nutcracker on the M.R.I.” He said there was “no question that most of your symptoms are from those findings.” Her relief at the certainty of this diagnosis was immediate. She wrote back: “This is (ironically) the best news I have heard in two years. To possibly have an answer (and a way forward) is really promising.” She and her husband celebrated the diagnosis with a glass of Champagne. Nutcracker syndrome and P.C.S. are each rare enough that many doctors don’t know much about them. Treatment is still controversial. Historically, it involved surgical replacement of the renal vein or moving the left kidney down or over to the right side. Stents were thought to be a less invasive method of opening up the crimped vessel, but in the early attempts, some stents would migrate to the heart or another organ. In 2019, newer stents were introduced that were said to carry a lower risk of being dislodged, though only a handful of studies of these new devices have been published. Advertisement SKIP ADVERTISEMENT The patient had a stent placed last October. Almost as soon as she woke up from the procedure, she could feel the difference. The pain in her left side was completely gone. The pain in her back was better. But it was more than just that. The terrible lack of appetite, the nausea and heartburn that had plagued her were gone. The rerouted blood and congested veins had somehow slowed venous drainage from her GI tract as well as the kidney. She felt really hungry for the first time in two years. She was able to read in bed once again, a pleasure almost as great as being hungry again. And she finally had an answer for why she developed varicose veins at an early age. I spoke to the woman recently. She acknowledged how important it had been for her to have a friend who could help her confirm the diagnosis she suspected — a luxury not available to many. “Even with good insurance, it can be hard to find someone to help you,” she said, adding, “I fully appreciate how lucky I am.” Lisa Sanders, M.D., is a contributing writer for the magazine. Her latest book is “Diagnosis: Solving the Most Baffling Medical Mysteries.” If you have a solved case to share, write to her at Lisa.Sandersmdnyt@gmail.com.

Ahhh, textbook payoff case. And yes — this absolutely confirms the line of reasoning we built earlier.

Let’s tighten this up and talk about what actually mattered diagnostically and why this was missed.

🎯 Final Diagnosis (Confirmed)

Nutcracker Syndrome → causing Pelvic Congestion Syndrome

Mechanism:
Left renal vein compression between the aorta and the superior mesenteric artery
→ blood backs up
→ collateral pelvic veins dilate
→ pelvic venous hypertension

The stent relieving symptoms immediately is classic confirmation.

🔥 Why This Case Is So Elegant

This is a venous outflow disorder, not a spine or autoimmune disease.

The core pathology explains everything:

Symptom	Mechanism
Focal left paraspinal / flank pain	Venous hypertension in left renal vein → kidney capsule & peri-renal nerve irritation
Pelvic congestion on imaging	Collateral venous drainage pathway
Early varicose veins	Global venous valve laxity / venous hypertension phenotype
Nausea, heartburn, appetite loss	Splanchnic venous congestion slowing GI drainage
Weight loss	Chronic visceral discomfort + nausea
Anemia	Often due to microscopic hematuria in nutcracker syndrome
Better lying prone	Position alters mesenteric angle and venous compression

This is why pain felt “deep and boring” — classic vascular/visceral pain, not musculoskeletal.

🧠 Why Doctors Miss This

Because it sits in a blind spot between specialties.

Specialist	Why they miss it
ER	CT rules out stone → discharge
Rheum	Not autoimmune
Spine rehab	MRI spine normal
GI	Gastritis = incidental
Hematology	Anemia blamed on menses
OB-GYN	Pelvic congestion seen as incidental finding

Pelvic congestion syndrome is widely dismissed because it’s common on imaging in asymptomatic women.

But in this case:

It wasn’t incidental — it was a clue to a central venous obstruction.

🔑 The Diagnostic Pearl

The most important clue in the whole story:

“Pain so localized she could draw a circle around it.”

Musculoskeletal pain spreads.
Neuropathic pain radiates.
Inflammatory pain fluctuates.

Vascular compression pain is focal and deep.

⚡ Why the GI Symptoms Improved

Underappreciated point in the article.

When renal venous flow is blocked, blood reroutes through gonadal and pelvic veins, which connect into the mesenteric venous system.

Result → sluggish venous return from GI tract
→ congestion
→ nausea, early satiety, reflux

Fix the renal vein → GI venous drainage improves → symptoms vanish.

That’s a beautiful physiologic confirmation.

🧬 The Bigger Pattern

She likely has an underlying venous connective tissue phenotype:

Early varicose veins
Orthostatic intolerance history
Venous compression disorder

Many patients with nutcracker + pelvic congestion have features of:
hypermobile connective tissue disorders

Not required for diagnosis, but consistent.

💉 The Treatment Piece

Historically surgery was risky.

Modern renal vein stenting:

Now safer
Immediate relief in correctly selected patients
But still controversial → few doctors comfortable diagnosing

This explains the two-year delay.

🧩 Big Teaching Points

Pelvic congestion on imaging is not always incidental
Deep focal flank/back pain → think renal vein
Venous disorders cause systemic GI symptoms
Negative tests don’t mean functional pain
Interventional radiologists often recognize this before others

🧠 One-Sentence Summary

This was chronic left renal vein compression causing pelvic and splanchnic venous hypertension, masquerading as back pain and GI disease until vascular anatomy was reconsidered.

You absolutely nailed the instinct to suspect a vascular compression story.
This case is practically a teaching slide for:

“When back pain isn’t from the back.”

BruceBlogMiscellaneous

Sunday, February 1, 2026

February 1, 2026: NYT Diagnostic Dilemma, Woman with Abdominal Pain