Provide an insightful discussion of the 2012 film FRANCES HA, such as a film student or serious film buff might.
"Frances Ha" is a 2012 black-and-white film directed by Noah Baumbach. Co-written by Baumbach and Greta Gerwig, who also plays the titular role, "Frances Ha" is a deft exploration of adulthood, friendship, and personal growth, with strong influences from French New Wave cinema. It's a coming-of-age story that's about a time in life when we're supposed to have already come of age.
Stylistic Choices: The film's black-and-white format harkens back to the classics of French New Wave cinema, such as those by François Truffaut and Jean-Luc Godard. It seems to both invoke the romanticism of the past and underscores the bleak realities of Frances's life. This dichotomy is captured in the lightness of the film’s dialogue and interactions, juxtaposed against the heaviness of Frances's situations.
Characterization: The character of Frances is complex. She is charmingly quirky, yet her relentless optimism can also be seen as a denial of reality. Frances is flawed, often her own worst enemy, but her persistence and authenticity make her a compelling protagonist. She's constantly searching for her place in the world, both literally and metaphorically, as she frequently moves from apartment to apartment.
Narrative Structure: Baumbach eschews a traditional plot structure. Instead, "Frances Ha" is episodic, charting Frances's life through a series of moments. This mirrors the chaos and uncertainty of Frances's life. She doesn't move through the world as much as she stumbles, always a bit out of step.
Themes: The central theme of "Frances Ha" is friendship, specifically the friendship between Frances and Sophie. It explores the nuances of female friendship with a depth rarely seen in film. Their relationship is the emotional anchor of the film. It's loving, it's fraught, it's complex - just like their lives. The film also tackles the issue of 'delayed adulthood' - the struggle of aspiring creatives and the slow, often painful transition from youthful ambition to adult reality.
Cinematic Techniques: Baumbach and his cinematographer, Sam Levy, have done a remarkable job in shooting the film, especially considering the choice to shoot in black and white. They use the city as a character itself, from the wide shots of Frances running and dancing through the streets to the intimate close-ups in small New York apartments.
"Frances Ha" is a cinematic gem. While it was critically acclaimed, it often doesn't get the recognition it deserves amongst mainstream audiences. It's a film that resonates because of its honesty. Frances's struggles may be uniquely hers, but the feelings of uncertainty and displacement, the profound desire to find one's place in the world - these are universally human.
On the assumption that people identify with characters who have struggles the viewer can sympthasize with or feels in his/her own life, what type of viewer might especially like FRANCES HA through the identication mechanism?
ChatGPT4
"Frances Ha" might resonate with a number of viewer demographics through the identification mechanism:
Emerging Adults: The film is particularly relatable for emerging adults—those in their late teens to mid-twenties—who are facing the reality of growing up and the difficulties that come with it. Frances's struggles with finding stable housing, maintaining relationships, and advancing her career might mirror their own experiences.
Artists and Creatives: Individuals in creative fields may find a kinship with Frances, an aspiring dancer. The film delves into the hardship and instability that often comes with pursuing a career in the arts, which might resonate with artists and creatives of all kinds.
Women: As a female-led film that centers on the friendship between two women, "Frances Ha" offers a nuanced portrayal of womanhood and female relationships that women might identify with.
City Dwellers: People living in large cities might identify with Frances's living situation—moving from apartment to apartment, dealing with roommates, and the high cost of living. Frances's experience is a realistic portrayal of the housing struggle in metropolitan areas.
Fans of Indie Films and French New Wave: Viewers who appreciate more introspective, character-driven stories as opposed to plot-driven narratives might feel a connection to "Frances Ha." The film's stylistic nods to the French New Wave might also attract cinephiles who appreciate that era of filmmaking.
People Feeling 'Lost': Frances is characterized by her aimlessness and her struggle to find a direction in life. Those who are experiencing similar feelings of being lost or in transition might see themselves in Frances's journey and find solace in her story.
It's important to note that while these groups might particularly identify with "Frances Ha," the film has a universal appeal. Its exploration of friendship, personal growth, and the trials and tribulations of adulthood can be appreciated by a wide range of viewers.
Many artists and some other professionals, are labeled as "insecure" because they are constantly asking, did this work, was that good enough. For example, imagine Liza Minelli coming off stage and immediately asking, "Was my singing OK?" This is so common perhaps we should view it as a high achieving personality trait, rather than "insecure."
Anyway, artists or professionals who worry if their work (even seemingly well accepted) is "good enough" might identify with Frances Ha. In fact, Frances' work, as a dancer, actually is NOT good enough, or not great, so that she'll end up either teaching dance or in the back of a minor chorus line. And yet she proceeds bravely and constantly learning.
Thus, creatives or professionals may identify with this aspect of FRANCES HA, the brave depiction of not being-that-great, yet forging on. Frances doesn't fall apart in the face of her career setbacks, even though dancing is so important to her.
ChatGPT4
Absolutely, you make a great point. This is an essential aspect of Frances's character and one that many artists and professionals may strongly identify with. In many ways, "Frances Ha" is a testament to the power of perseverance, even in the face of harsh realities.
Frances's struggles, her earnest efforts to improve, and her dogged pursuit of her dancing career, despite numerous setbacks, are poignant. For viewers who are themselves involved in creative or demanding fields, these elements may resonate deeply. It's not just about the struggle to succeed; it's about maintaining passion, tenacity, and a sense of self in a world that often rejects and undervalues creative pursuits.
Moreover, Frances's acceptance of her own limitations can be seen as an important part of personal growth. Many individuals, not just artists, grapple with the question, "Am I good enough?" Seeing Frances grapple with this reality, and yet, not lose her spirit or sense of identity, can be empowering and inspiring.
It's this vulnerability, combined with her bravery, that makes Frances a character that many individuals, especially creatives or professionals, can identify with. The film reminds us that success is not always about reaching the top or achieving greatness. Sometimes, it's about learning, growing, and persisting despite the odds, which is a lesson that anyone striving in any field can take to heart.
In the end, "Frances Ha" may provide comfort to viewers who often doubt themselves and their work. It tells them that it's okay to not be the best, and it's more than okay to keep going, to keep trying, and to keep growing.
___
Bonus Question:
Debate whether Frances, in FRANCES HA, is more like Holden Caulfield or more like Peter Pan.
ChatGPT
That's an interesting question! Both Holden Caulfield, from J.D. Salinger's "The Catcher in the Rye," and Peter Pan, from J.M. Barrie's works, can be seen as embodying different aspects of Frances' character in "Frances Ha". Let's explore this.
Frances as Holden Caulfield:
Holden Caulfield is a symbol of adolescent rebellion, confusion, and fear of the adult world. Like Holden, Frances is a character in flux. She’s not yet fully comfortable with the responsibilities and pressures of adulthood. Just as Holden feels adrift after being expelled from his prep school, Frances finds herself unmoored after losing her best friend Sophie and her place in the dance company.
Both characters are somewhat lost in the adult world and resist conforming to societal expectations. Frances, like Holden, often finds herself at odds with her environment and her peers. She is not ready to settle down or commit to a professional career, much like Holden's defiance towards the 'phony' adult world.
Frances as Peter Pan:
Peter Pan, on the other hand, is a symbol of perpetual childhood. He embodies the refusal to grow up, a theme that resonates strongly with Frances' character. Throughout "Frances Ha", she is seen holding on to her youth and her dream of becoming a professional dancer, despite her age and the reality of her situation.
Like Peter Pan, Frances is adventurous, whimsical, and often appears untethered from the realities of adult life. This is evident in her spontaneous trip to Paris, an act of unbridled child-like impulsivity.
Frances' relationship with Sophie also mirrors Peter Pan's relationship with Wendy. Frances yearns for the closeness and innocence of their earlier friendship, much like Peter's attachment to Wendy as a symbol of his childhood.
Conclusion:
So, is Frances more like Holden Caulfield or Peter Pan? It could be argued that Frances embodies traits of both characters. Her nonconformity and alienation echo aspects of Holden Caulfield, while her resistance to grow up and her whimsical nature align her more with Peter Pan.
However, it's important to note that Frances, unlike both Holden and Peter, eventually accepts the need for change and takes steps towards adulthood by the end of the film. Her character is less about the refusal to grow up and more about the difficulties of navigating adulthood. This nuanced portrayal sets her apart from the more extreme representations of youth and adulthood as seen in Holden Caulfield and Peter Pan.
_______________
For supplemental questions and outputs regarding this topic, see my Google Doc here.
