Consider a world where, instead of focusing on producing handicrafts or beer, Benedictine monks produce movies to raise funds for their order. (Note, Benedictine monks do not have a vow of silence). Imagine a world where the monks of a Benedictine abbey near Vienna have produced the script and directed THE THIRD MAN. (It is still set in 1948). How would the film be different?
ChatGPT
Benedictine monks follow the teachings of Saint Benedict, who emphasized balance, moderation, and reasonableness in all things. Their motto is "Ora et Labora" ("Pray and Work"), which outlines their dedication to prayer, study, and manual labor. Given this background, a version of "The Third Man" produced by Benedictine monks might feature some substantial changes.
Storyline: The monks might opt for a plot that mirrors their values and teachings. Harry Lime could be a man who lost his way due to greed and betrayal, but the story could focus more on his redemption and the impact of his actions on the community.
Themes: The themes of the film might be heavily influenced by Benedictine values such as community, hospitality, humility, and the pursuit of peace. The film could explore the destructive consequences of greed, deceit, and immorality, promoting reflection and introspection.
Style: The visual style of the film might shift to reflect the monks' simple and austere lifestyle. It might have a less frantic pace, creating space for reflection and contemplation. The famous zither music could be replaced by Gregorian chant or other types of religious music, setting a contemplative tone for the film.
Character Interactions: Dialogue could become more profound and reflective, focusing on moral dilemmas and philosophical issues. The relationships between characters might reflect Benedictine ideals of brotherhood, community, and mutual respect.
Setting: The film would still be set in post-war Vienna, but the monks could choose to emphasize the role of the Church and religious faith in rebuilding society after the war.
Ending: The original film's bleak ending might be replaced by one that emphasizes redemption, reconciliation, and the power of faith. Instead of leaving Harry Lime in the sewers, the monks could provide him a chance for redemption and a return to moral righteousness.
In this speculative scenario, "The Third Man" would likely reflect the Benedictine monks' commitment to moral and spiritual teachings, shaping a different yet thought-provoking version of the classic film.
