Can you compare and contrast the role of the Stage Manager in the play Our Town with the role of the Narrator in the musical Into the Woods?
#
The stage manager in Our Town by Thornton Wilder and the narrator in Into the Woods by Stephen Sondheim and James Lapine both serve as essential narrative devices, but their roles differ in purpose, tone, and interaction with the characters and audience.
Similarities:
Breaking the Fourth Wall: Both characters directly address the audience, guiding them through the story. The stage manager provides exposition about the town, its people, and the passage of time, while the narrator in Into the Woods sets up the intertwining fairy tales and explains the broader moral lessons.
Omniscient Perspective: Both figures have an all-knowing view of the events and characters. The stage manager speaks about past, present, and future events in Our Town, and the narrator has a bird’s-eye view of the action in Into the Woods, knowing how each character’s journey will unfold.
Narrative Framing: Each character helps to frame the play or musical’s structure. The stage manager organizes the scenes, time shifts, and transitions in Our Town, while the narrator provides a cohesive thread in Into the Woods, knitting together disparate fairy tales into one overarching narrative.
Differences:
Role in the Plot: The stage manager in Our Town stays outside the story, remaining an observer who shapes the audience’s experience without interfering in the action. The narrator in Into the Woods begins as a non-participant but becomes part of the story when the characters blame him for their misfortunes and eventually eliminate him from the narrative.
Tone and Style: The stage manager's tone is conversational, calm, and reflective, often philosophical, as he meditates on life, death, and the passage of time. The narrator in Into the Woods, by contrast, often has a whimsical, ironic tone, in keeping with the fairy tale setting. While he reflects on the moral implications of the characters’ choices, he does so with humor and detachment until his demise.
Interaction with Characters: The stage manager interacts minimally with the characters in Our Town, only when necessary to introduce them or set up a scene. In Into the Woods, the narrator begins as detached but is eventually dragged into the story, showing a more dynamic relationship with the characters as they challenge his role in their fate.
In summary, while both the stage manager and the narrator serve to guide and inform the audience, the stage manager is more of an impartial, reflective figure, while the narrator of Into the Woods is more deeply embedded in the action, ultimately becoming a victim of the characters’ frustrations. Their roles reflect the thematic goals of each work: Our Town’s focus on the quiet universality of life and death, and Into the Woods’s exploration of the complexities and consequences of storytelling and wish fulfillment.
#
James Lapine wrote the book for Into the Woods. Lapine must have been aware his narrator is a bit like the stage manager in the extremely well known, Our Town.
#
Yes, it's highly likely that James Lapine was aware of the similarities between his narrator in Into the Woods and the stage manager in Thornton Wilder's Our Town. Given the iconic status of Our Town, and Lapine’s deep engagement with theatrical traditions, the parallels in how both characters function as meta-narrative guides—breaking the fourth wall, providing exposition, and reflecting on the human condition—suggest a deliberate nod or at least an awareness of this dramatic device.
Our Town’s stage manager is a classic example of a character who steps outside the action to give the audience a broader, often philosophical perspective, much like the narrator in Into the Woods, who connects disparate fairy tales and comments on their meaning. The device of having an all-seeing figure who engages both with the audience and the story itself, even in moments of reflection or humor, seems like a natural inheritance from Wilder’s play.
Lapine may have drawn inspiration from Our Town’s use of minimalism and self-aware narration to craft a narrator who similarly illuminates the moral and thematic undercurrents of the action, though he takes it a step further by having the narrator become part of the story’s unraveling. This would add a layer of self-referential commentary, acknowledging both the narrator’s control and ultimate vulnerability, in contrast to the more detached and eternal stage manager in Our Town.
#
Do any other modern theatrical works come to mind which have so prominent a narrator as our two examples inthis dialogue?
#
Yes, several modern theatrical works feature prominent narrators who, like the stage manager in Our Town and the narrator in Into the Woods, play central roles in shaping the audience's understanding of the story and breaking the fourth wall. Here are a few notable examples:
1. Pippin (Stephen Schwartz, Roger O. Hirson)
The character known as the Leading Player serves as a narrator and guide throughout the musical Pippin. Much like the stage manager and the narrator in Into the Woods, the Leading Player orchestrates the events of the show and interacts with both the characters and the audience. The Leading Player’s role, however, is more manipulative, as they influence the protagonist’s journey and even encourage the audience to question the nature of the performance itself.
2. The Rocky Horror Show (Richard O’Brien)
In The Rocky Horror Show, a character known simply as the Narrator or Criminologist serves as an omniscient observer, guiding the audience through the bizarre and campy plot. The Narrator offers commentary on the characters’ actions, much like the detached and knowing narrators of Our Town and Into the Woods, but with a more humorous and ironic tone, fitting the show’s cult status and playful, transgressive style.
3. The Drowsy Chaperone (Lisa Lambert, Greg Morrison, Bob Martin, Don McKellar)
In The Drowsy Chaperone, the character known as Man in Chair acts as a narrator who directly addresses the audience, introducing them to his favorite musical (which comes to life as he listens to it). Similar to the stage manager in Our Town, Man in Chair provides personal commentary, guiding the audience through the musical within a musical while offering insights and humor about the production. The role is meta-theatrical and highly interactive, blurring the lines between narrator and audience member.
4. Blood Brothers (Willy Russell)
The Narrator in Blood Brothers serves as a central figure who comments on the events of the musical, reflecting on themes of fate, superstition, and social class. He weaves in and out of the story, often delivering foreboding lines that remind the audience of the tragic ending, much like the philosophical reflections in Our Town and Into the Woods.
5. Peter and the Starcatcher (Rick Elice)
This play, which serves as a prequel to Peter Pan, features an ensemble of narrators who break the fourth wall and narrate the story directly to the audience. The narration in Peter and the Starcatcher is highly stylized and self-aware, with the narrators taking on various roles within the story while maintaining an outsider’s perspective. Like the stage manager and the narrator in Into the Woods, the narrators here provide both exposition and commentary, adding humor and insight into the action.
These examples highlight how modern theater continues to use the narrator as a vital, often meta-theatrical device. Each of these narrators, in different ways, serves to guide, comment on, or influence the events of the story, much like the stage manager in Our Town and the narrator in Into the Woods.
#
Rocky Horror! Yes. One might add the character of TOM in "Glass Menagerie."
#
You're absolutely right! Tom in The Glass Menagerie is another excellent example of a narrator who, much like the stage manager in Our Town and the narrator in Into the Woods, steps outside the action of the play to speak directly to the audience. His role as a memory-based narrator allows for a reflective, somewhat unreliable perspective, as he recalls events from his past. This adds a layer of emotional depth and nostalgia, as Tom grapples with his own guilt and longing. His function as both a participant in the story and its storyteller makes him a fascinating example of this theatrical device.
